print view
English 800.301
Teaching of Literature and Composition
James English profile

T 12-3

Our primary aim in this course is to facilitate good teaching in English 3 and in your subsequent, self-structured English Writing classes. A good deal of the preparation and discussion for English 800 will thus be directly keyed to what you are doing in English 3, and in particular to the teaching of writing. I will visit your class twice, look at papers you have graded, and meet with you to discuss your teaching. I will also consult regularly with the two graduate-student mentors about how the English 3 classes are going, and modify 800 accordingly. Our secondary, and not unrelated, aim is to work out some broader cultural and pedagogical issues connected with the journalistic fetishes of "scandal" and "controversy," the notion of a "culture war," and the new pedagogical imperative to "teach the conflicts." In what ways are these conflicts or wars being misrepresented, misdiagnosed, mistaught? Can we abandon the paradigm of "controversy" without capitulating to some false utopia of consensus or of discourse untainted by violence? Toward this aim, we will be reading a number of essays by theorists of education and pedagogy, and staging a mini-conference on "Controversial Approaches to Pedagogy / Pedagogical Approaches to Controversy" in two sessions at the end of the semester.

Requirements and Grading

On the schedule, below, you will see three categories of assignment for each of our class meetings: Teaching Prep, 800 Prep, and Presentations. In the final weeks of the semester, Presentations will take the form of Conference Papers and Spring Syllabi. Grades for English 800 will be based on how well you accomplish all of this required work as well as on my assessment of how responsible and effective you have been as a teacher of English 3.

Books, Films, Bulkpack

Schedule

Note that while the five units of the course as indicated below correspond to those on the English 3 syllabus, our own readings and preparations for English 800 tend to run ahead of this schedule by about a week. This is especially evident in the early weeks of the term, since we will be meeting twice--on Aug 29 and Sept 2--before the English 3 semester officially begins.

You can take shortcuts to: unit 1, weeks 2-3 (Conrad) | unit 2, weeks 4-6 (Heather, Culture Wars) | unit 3, weeks 7-8 (Kids, Right Thing) | unit 4, weeks 9-10 (Santiago) | unit 5, weeks 11-13 (Rushdie)

Introductions: Aug 28, Sept 2

Aug 28 (2:15-5:00)

Teaching Prep: Modify the master syllabus as appropriate for your class. (Note that it is a Tuesday/Thursday syllabus. If you are teaching MWF, you will need to decide how to space assignments, discussions, and workshops across three sessions a week.) Use the first class meeting, Sept 4 or 5 to go over syllabus, grading and attendance policies, goals and expectations, portfolios, and email/listserv/web page basics. Some suggestions and guidelines can be found on the master syllabus. Establish some ongoing writing assignments -- e.g., listserve posts (1/2 class every Monday by 5PM, 1/2 class every Wed by 5PM) with a 300-word maximum, in response to some discussion question(s) that you provide each week. You can save these posts in separate file folders for each student and review them with the final portfolios. Set aside 15 minutes of the first class meeting for a diagnostic writing exercise such as a one-paragraph self-characterization focusing on literary or artistic background and interests. Use these to get a rough sense of where your base line is, as well as to learn something about your students and to begin matching names to faces. Get started reading Heart of Darkness. 800 Prep: Go through all the pages of this syllabus and make a list of questions or concerns. Make a note to put Satanic Verses on your 50-book list. Read through the writing handbook and diagnose your own weaknesses regarding grammar, syntax, and punctuation. Do you know whether commas and semi-colons go on the inside or outside of single quotation marks? double quotation marks? Do you know when to use "whom"? Do you know the difference between "that" nd "which"? Can you identify a dangling participle or misplaced modifier? All of these problems, and many others, will come up in your students' papers. If you are shaky on these sorts of things, as I certainly was when I started teaching freshman English, now is the time to start working on them. Jack Lynch's Resources for Writers and Writing Instructors and his Grammar and Style Guide can be useful references for you as well as your students. Discussion: Goals and agenda; master syllabus and individual modifications; things to do in your first class meeting; diagnostic writing and two paradigms of composition pedagogy (correcting errors vs fostering confidence and creativity); striking the right balance of freindship/professionalism. Presentations: None

Sept 2

Teaching Prep: As above. Read Heart of Darkness 800 Prep: As above. Discussion: Heart of Darkness; teaching literature and teaching writing. How to get started. Presentations: None

Unit 1: Classic Literature and its Discontents -- Conrad's Heart of Darkness

Sept 9

Teaching Prep: Finish reading Heart of Darkness and work out an approach to it that will give your students scope to react openly and spontaneously to the book while also allowing you to point up the gap between their acts of reception and the context of the novel's production. Read Achebe's "Image of Africa," Sarvan's rejoinder, and Denby's "Jungle Fever." Evaluate the diagnostic paragraphs and prepare some general remarks about these for your class. Read through the listserve posts and print out some provocative or useful ones for use in class. Look over the teaching materials discussed in today's Presentation. Get the first essay assignment ready for distribution and discussion. Prepare to talk about the difference between a topic and a thesis, and about more and less effective ways to support a thesis. 800 Prep: Graff, "Teach the Conflicts" in Gless and Smth; D. G. Myers, "Invitation to an Argument: Gerald Graff's 'Conflict Model' of Education" (bulkpack); Lunsford and Duffey, "Graff's Project and the Teaching of Writing" (bulkpack) Discussion: How to "teach the conflicts." Reductive debate versus circular chatter -- training for law school vs training for journalism: two unattractive pedagogical options. The place of literary study in the academy and of literary criticism in the broader culture. Presentations Useful criticism and background on Heart of Darkness: Louis Cabri

Sept 16

Teaching Prep: Evaluate first essays, with focus on whether they establish a clear position and support it systematically. You will need to set up 20-minute individual conferences to discuss these essays in their revised form; schedule the conferences for next week and, if necessary, the week after. Since you will be discussing the essays with the students, you don't need to write as much commentary on them as you would ordinarily. 800 Prep: Guillory, "Writing without Reading" (bulkpack); Elbow, "The War Between Reading and Writing and How to End It" (orientation pack) Discussion: Teaching how to read and teaching how to write (the literature vs. composition debate). Integrating the two agenda: does the English Writing program doom us to schizo-pedagogy? One-hour workshop on grading/evaluating student work. Everyone bring in 10 copies of one of their student essays for this workshop; choose an essay that is either unusually good, unusually poor, or unusually difficult to evaluate. You may copy it with or without your marginal comments. Presentation: Teaching materials on Heather Has Two Mommies: Alice Brittan

Unit 2: Culture, Sexuality, and the Public Sphere: Heather Has Two Mommies, Mapplethorpe, and the NEA debates

Sept 23

Teaching Prep: Heather Has Two Mommies, and related readings. Prepare essay assignment for essay due Oct 2 -- 3-4 page editorial column on culture and school curriculum or on culture and taxpayers. Look at the Pollitt and Will pieces for examples of the editorial column. 800 Prep: Freire, Pedagogy of the Oppressed, chapters 1-2. Nelson, Manifesto, section II. Discussion: Approaches to the Heather debate: moving students beyond pro-and-con (e.g., radical critique of the family). More general discussion of the issues in this unit of the course and how to teach them: culture and the problem of autonomy; art and social purpose; democracy vs. "taxpayers' rights"; public schools, public arts grants, public television. How to get beyond the rhetoric of arts-bashing and arts-defending to recognize the stakes of art. Discussion of sexual (and other) identities in the classroom. How can an instructor foster difference, manage difference? What is the instructor's responsibility as regards his/her own identifications? Presentation: Culture Wars materials, NEA background: Brent Stinsky

Sept 30

Teaching Prep: Culture Wars anthology readings. Prepare a workshop, and perhaps handouts, on argument vs. opinion, logic and evidence vs. rhetorical intensity. 800 Prep: Freire, Pedagogy of the Oppressed, chapters 3-4; Sedgwick, "Pedagogy in the Context of an Antihomophobic Project" in Gless and Smith. Nelson, Manifesto, section I - chaps 1 & 2. Discussion: Sexuality as a pedagogical problem: harrassment, homophobia, irate parents, etc. Correct thinking and the aims of teaching. Tolerance and other liberal values. Presentation: Teaching materials on Kids, history of realism in film: Lisa Martinez

Unit 3: Suburban Fears, Urban "Realities": Kids, Do the Right Thing, Gangsta Rap

Oct 7

Teaching Prep: View Kids and Do the Right Thingat least once, read the reviews and essays online [link to be added here]. Prepare assignment for 3-4-page movie review. 800 Prep: Pinney, Short Handbook, Lanham, Style: An Anti-Textbook Discussion: Teaching film: realism and convention. Teaching style in connection with aims and audience: e.g., the movie-review style versus styles of film criticism or film theory. Presentations: Materials for teaching Do the Right Thing Materials for teaching the "gangsta rap" (tapes, videos, 'zines, scholarly resources: Mark Rifkin? [We should decide if we want to do a ResNet viewing of some kind for the gangsta rap classes -- Boyz in the Hood or music videos.]

Oct 14

[FALL BREAK -- When your class meets this week, be sure to schedule conferences for next week and the week after.]

Oct 21

Teaching Prep: Gangsta rap readings. Prepare some materials for this class, possibly including tapes or videos (based on Oct 7 presentation). Prepare to lead the style workshop this week. 800 Prep:
Discussion: Difficulties of teaching non-literary texts: the tendency to overemphasize lyrics when teaching music, for example. Can the study of vernacular expressive forms help a student to master the academic style of writing? What is the academic style of writing, and do we really want our students to master it? Presentation: Danny Santiago and Little Tree: teaching materials on ethnicity and authenticity: Anna Ivy

Unit 4: Culture and the Scandal of Inauthenticity: Danny Santiago's Famous All Over Town

Oct 28

Teaching Prep: Santiago, Famous All Over Town, related readings. Prepare assignment on imitation (2-3-page imitations of Chato's voice and manner, recounting a day or part of a day on Penn campus; 1/2 class does parody, 1/2 class does pastiche.) Prepare workshop on voice, imitation, cultural flattery vs. cultural mockery, etc. Prepare assignment for essays on race and authenticity (these are due Nov 6). 800 Prep: Guillory, excerpt from Cultural Capital, chapter one (bulkpack); Foucault, "What Is an Author?" (bulkpack) Discussion: Is it possible, desirable to teach ethnic literature without unitary authorial subjects, authentic voices, representative texts, and etc? What difference does it make who is speaking? Using imitation as a writing exercise and in the classroom. Presentations Ethnicity and literature: Cindy Port

Nov 4

Teaching Prep: Finish preparing Famous All Over Town. Prepare workshop on writing a literary-critical essay, focusing on expectations about readers: what needs to be explained and what doesn't, when to use plot summary, how to integrate quotations from a text and to use them effectively as evidence, etc. 800 Prep: Online catalogue about Discipliary Procedures, Plagiarism, Violations of the Academic Code; Foucault, Discipline and Punish excerpts (bulkpack); examples of plagiarized papers (online or hand-out). Discussion: Literary criticism and readerly expectations. Plagiarism, academic codes, academic discipline. Presentations: Possible presentation by Michelle Goldfarb, Director of Student Dispute Resolution Center. Presentation on Satanic Verses affair: American repercussions _____________________

Nov 11

Teaching Prep: Read as much of Satanic Verses as possible; begin readin excerpts from The Rushdie Affair; think about what kind of final papers you want your students to write and how to get them started on these even before they've finished the novel. 800 Prep: None Discussion: How to teach a long, difficult novel. Getting started with the Verses. Presentations: Plagiarism controversies: Roots, White Hotel _________________________ Satanic Verses' Islamic backgrounds: the Koran: Erika Williams

Unit 5: Culture and the Sacred: Satanic Verses for American Readers

Nov 18

Teaching Prep: Complete the Verses. Prepare final essay assignment. Remember to schedule final conferences for next week and the week after. 800 Prep: Conference Papers Discussion: Half of this class will be devoted to discussion of the Verses Affair and how to teach it. What are the stakes for non-Muslim American critics and readers? What are some secular American equivalents to the sacred? (e.g., the child? "artistic freedom"?) The second half of this class meeting will begin our Conference on pedagogy and controversy in the contemporary academy. Presentations: Mini-conference, Session One: Four conference-type papers, 15-20 mins each (shoot for 15 minutes; 20 minutes is the absolute cut-off), on "Controversial Approaches to Pedagogy / Pedagogical Approaches to Controversy." Brief Question and Answer period after presentations.

Our presenters today are:

Nov 25

Teaching Prep: 800 Prep: Conference Papers Discussion: Conference Presentations: Mini-Conference, Sessions Two and Three: Two sets of three conference-type papers, 15-20 mins each, on "Controversial Approaches to Pedagogy / Pedagogical Approaches to Controversy." Question and Answer period at end of each session. Presenters for today's sessions are:

SESSION TWO

SESSION THREE

Dec 2

Teaching Prep: 800 Prep: Get your spring syllabus ready, make enough copies for everyone in the class, and prepare to discuss them with the group. Discussion: Spring syllabi Presentations: Spring Syllabi


updated 2006-10-12
 
 
 
 


©2008 Trustees of the University of Pennsylvania
Photo caption: Francis Daniel Pastorius, Beehive manuscript, 1696-1865, Rare Book and Manuscript Library, University of Pennsylvania.
Webmaster/Contact: briankir@english.upenn.edu